Comment & Analysis
Oct 11, 2026

What does the Defence Agenda mean for Ireland’s EU Presidency?

Ireland will face challenge in the months ahead as it seeks to lead on the EU’s most consequential defence agenda in a generation without compromising Irish neutrality

Alannah WrynnContributing Writer

Almost halfway through Ireland’s six month presidency of the council of the EU, many of Ireland’s diplomatic and security challenges still lie ahead. 12 November will see the 9th gathering of the European Political Community (EPC) in Dublin, bringing together all heads of state or government along with the heads of many European and international institutions. The leaders of the 27 EU member states will then meet informally on 13 November. The security challenge posed by the hosting of these two events should not be understated and shines a light on Irish defence capabilities at a time when the future of European security is dominating the EU agenda. French and British warships were requested by Ireland to assist in providing air defence during Ireland’s EU presidency due to a lack of Irish military capabilities. Ireland is also currently working on acquiring the country’s first long-range military radar systems. 

Irish lack of defence capabilities has certainly drawn criticism, with Irish waters being branded by the Wall Street Journal as NATO’s ‘blind spot’, referencing the fact that 75% of transatlantic sub-sea cables pass through Irish waters and could be vulnerable to Russian sabotage. Ireland is the EU’s lowest defence spender, spending 0.24% of GDP on their defence budget, and is also one of the few EU member states to not be a member of NATO. Yet increasing Ireland’s defence capabilities has appeared as an Irish government priority, and as Ireland is given the responsibility of forwarding the EU security agenda, the question is raised of what this means for the future of Irish neutrality.

On the diplomatic front, a major challenge facing Ireland is negotiations on the Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) 2028-2034. Ireland is responsible for forwarding negotiations and ensuring agreement between all EU member states on the EU’s seven year budget. This budget is expected to be worth €2 trillion and is aimed to be implemented by 2027. Ireland will be expected to present a negotiation box in October. Here again, defence as well as competitiveness have emerged as defining issues. European Commission proposals have included allocating €131 billion towards investment in defence, security and space. This would see investment increasing fivefold in comparison to previous budgets. These funds are to be provided through the EU competitiveness fund, highlighting the connections between EU competitiveness and security priorities.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite Irish military neutrality, there is little to indicate that Ireland’s ability to lead on European security is being strongly questioned across Europe. The presidency has committed to addressing “Europe’s security in all its dimensions.” What the Irish presidency includes in this definition of security is of particular relevance as conversations around security can include environmental and food security, health security, economic security, maritime security, cybersecurity and critical infrastructure security. 

The official Irish presidency website references all of these forms of security as well as committing itself to “full implementation of the Pact on Migration and Asylum” and “progressing legislation to facilitate migrant returns and on digitalisation of returns.” This gives security a wide definition, incorporating issues outside of defence, some of which are more politically divisive than others.

President Ursula von der Leyen’s State of the Union address on 16 September referenced once more the need for a new European Security Strategy, which is expected to be delivered next month. Likely to be included is a new European Security Council which would include Ukraine, the UK, Norway and Canada along with an emergency security protocol that von der Leyen referred to as “a mechanism to flank NATO’s Article 4” for threats “which fall below armed aggression but clearly threaten our national security.” This proposition may prove concerning to those who perceive a threat to Irish neutrality by the EU’s goal of becoming a “fully-fledged European defence union.”

The mutual defence clause (Article 42.7 Treaty on European Union) states:

“If a Member State is the victim of armed aggression on its territory, the other Member States shall have towards it an obligation of aid and assistance by all the means in their power, in accordance with Article 51 of the United Nations Charter. This shall not prejudice the specific character of the security and defence policy of certain Member States.”

The last line of this clause, also known as the Irish clause, was only introduced following Irish rejection of the Lisbon treaty. It was also following concern that the Nice and Lisbon treaties undermined Irish neutrality and that the Triple Lock was created. In this way the question of how Ireland preserves its neutrality while being proactive members of the EU is not a new question, but it is one of growing pertinence, and that is being forced to adapt to a changing international landscape. 

The threat posed by Russia following the invasion of Ukraine has driven a prioritisation of defence across the EU that can be seen through the EU’s Defence Readiness Roadmap which aims to achieve defence readiness by 2030. It seeks to establish an Eastern Flank Watch, European Drone Defence Initiative, European Air Shield and European Space Shield. Meanwhile, the Military Mobility Package aims at ensuring more seamless movement of troops, equipment and military assets across the EU. 

In a contest between Irish neutrality and European security, it is the European defence movement that appears more organised and more prepared to formulate and implement new policy. Irish neutrality appears to suffer from a lack of a clear cross-party-supported definition of what distinguishes military and political neutrality. Irish neutrality is also placed in a weaker position by being a government policy, rather than enshrined in domestic or international law. 

Through Ireland’s presidency of the EU Council, Ireland is in the position to coordinate with other neutral nations, such as Austria and Malta, and ensure that neutral nations have their positions considered and respected within any EU defence policies or mechanisms. The level of threat perception across Europe when it comes to defence policy is unsurprisingly shaped by geographical distance from powers such as Russia as well as political realities within a variety of member states. Ireland’s challenge will be to attempt to bring all EU member states together and to lead on an EU security agenda without compromising its commitment to Irish neutrality.

Sign Up to Our Weekly Newsletters

Get The University Times into your inbox twice a week.