blank
Radius
Oct 15, 2026

Intellectualism and Its Antidote?

Trinity's Long Room via Wikimedia Commons
Caroline CronjaegerContributing Writer

The term has begun. Leaves are falling, coffee shops advertise anything pumpkin spice, and I sit in the library, hunched over my laptop, reading some theoretical core text that feels suspiciously like a random string of words that only have a vague relation to the English language as I know it.

Many a humanities student can likely relate. Our friends in STEM might think that we English majors simply read books all day, but — insert Boromir meme — one does not simply read Derrida, or Proust, or Gadamer. Instead, reading theory often feels like trying to build a racing car with technical skills that are already challenged by an IKEA flat pack.

Once you and your online dictionary have fought your way through the readings, the struggle is far from over. Now, you need to prove yourself in the arena of the classroom. Here, you score by using words with many syllables — extra points for terms in French (oeuvre) or German (Bildungsroman) — and by keeping up streaks of references to obscure philosophers and critics, and their even more obscure theories.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sometimes, I come home and think to myself: What the hell is it that I am doing here? Is there any value to these texts and discussions, or has the study of literature devolved into a grotesque contest of intellectual posturing in which language is merely used to signal one’s own academic superiority? Has academic language morphed from being the tool, into becoming the means itself?

In the realm of academia, every subject comes with its own terminology: mathematicians speak of isomorphisms, law students of “contra proferentem”, and medical students of dorisflexion. Though such terms are unintelligible to an outsider, there is a general good-faith assumption that they serve a specific purpose within their own fields. Why, then, am I suspicious of the language used within my own field? Or am I simply not smart enough to keep up?

Of course, language is primarily a means of exchanging information. Academic jargon enables efficient and precise communication of research questions and results. Especially in the literary field with its wide scope and its intersections with many other humanities, borrowing from other disciplines and drawing connections between concepts and theories encountered in different contexts undoubtedly enriches the discussion.

At the same time, language communicates the cultural capital one has access to. By dropping references to historical figures and texts carelessly, as if in passing, one signals casual acquaintance with certain theories and thinkers. The language of these theories becomes a sign of learnedness, academic status, and intellectuality.

In other fields, scholars can rely on crutches outside of language to create clarity. A mathematician may use equations and logical formulae to express meaning. These symbols can be substantiated by language, but they are ultimately unambiguous. Students of literary studies do not have any means of expression outside of language. And language proves to be a slippery tool, demanding to be applied rigorously.

The classroom discussion can then feel more like an academic pageant crowning those who perform intellectualism the best. It is easy to feel like an outsider in this environment. I have not read Proust or Derrida or Gadamer, and everyone else seems to be initiated into a realm of knowledge completely foreign to me. But I did read that one text by Habermas once, so I raise my hand in an effort to belong, to signal that I, too, understand, and that I, too, am an intellectual. And just like that, I am complicit.

So, where exactly is the line between the use of subject-specific language for the purpose of communicating information, and its use to signal one’s own inclusion in the club of literary intellectuals, that thrives on the exclusion of others? Like so many things, it comes down to intention. As soon as I refuse to include every single person in the room in a discussion, I enter into the intellectual circle-jerk of who is the most learned, the most enlightened, the most knowledgeable.

How does one walk the line between the precision and quality of a discussion, and its accessibility? How can we create an environment where discussions are inclusive and expansive at the same time? By leaving my ego at home. By asking questions. By listening carefully, by speaking kindly. And, most importantly, by admitting not to know.

Time to get back to Derrida.

Sign Up to Our Weekly Newsletters

Get The University Times into your inbox twice a week.