You’re seven years old. You’re locked in your room after committing the crime of what your mother calls “backtalk”. You’re sitting on your bed with a piece of paper and a pen. You’re not allowed to come out until you have written a substantial essay about what you did and why it is wrong.
This time, you’re twenty-one. You’re facing minor backlash after sexually assaulting an intoxicated twenty-year-old girl. Your university punishes you by assigning an essay. Your only penalty for sexually, physically, and psychologically abusing a young woman is to write about what you did and why it is wrong.
There are fourteen years between seven and twenty-one; yet, with each growing year, the idea of discipline for men remains fixed in its adolescent nature. Five out of seven of the “Cornell Seven”, a group of Cornell students belonging to the university’s Chi Phi fraternity, were not expelled nor charged for their participation in raping a female student, but rather punished through the “oh so retributive” act of essay writing.
We as a culture feel the need to protect and infantilize guilty young men at the expense of innocent young women, and it is safe to say college culture invites this kind of coddling like no other. Males between the ages of eighteen and twenty-two are often trademarked as having “promising futures”, ones so promising that any misdemeanor attached to their scrupulous reputations has to and must be whitewashed entirely. In accordance to the logic of rape sympathizers, a fraternity brother’s future working at J.P. Morgan is more important than justice for a survivor of abuse.
This kind of situation, one in which a university protects the oppressor, is not a new one; in fact, many of the women I know who are victims of sexual assault are utterly exhausted by their need to condemn such scenarios time and time again. My question is, how loudly do we need to suffer for someone to finally listen?
There is no coverage shortage of such injustice. Books have been written, movies have been filmed, articles have been published — yet, the same conversation persists. I think back to my first time watching Emerald Fennell’s 2020 Promising Young Woman, an Oscar-winning feature following Cassandra Thomas (played by Carey Mulligan) as she seeks revenge on her late best friend Nina’s rapists. In a scene between Cassandra and Dean Elizabeth Walker (played by Connie Britton), the Dean’s response to Cassandra’s confrontation is a deflection of her failure to intervene after learning about Nina’s rape when it occurred. She says: “What would you have me do? Ruin a man’s life every time we get an accusation like this?…I have to give him the benefit of the doubt.” To some, such a response might appear entirely absurd and unrealistic; but to many others, this kind of horizontal hostility feels all too familiar.
We have set a precedent for young men that lets them believe their misbehaviour will be undeniably protected. We have watched sex offenders time and time again gain unprecedented amounts of power, ultimately setting the stage for rapists to gain a sense of domination rather than face consequences for their actions. We have listened to convicted rapist Donald Trump sexualize his daughter and we have read his name in the Epstein files upwards of fifteen hundred times. We have excused artists like Roman Polanski and Anthony Kiedes for sexually exploiting and abusing minors because their talent somehow overrides their transgressions. We have allowed sexual predators to slip between the cracks, inviting the narrative that as long as you have money, fame, or influence, accountability is optional.
Matthew Ingalls, Jonathan Newell, Diego Sarabia, Gillio Lopes, Winston Lee, Scott Kretzschmar, and Scott Norris. This is the list of names belonging to the seven Cornell students who have been accused of drugging and raping a young woman. The assault occurred in 2024, yet it took nearly two years for Cornell’s president, Michael Kotlikoff, to either portray any kind of remorse for the victim or reprimand the seven assaulters at hand. Kotlikoff’s handling of such an incident, one in which the perpetrators of a gang rape are only denounced in the midst of escelating media coverage and attention, is nothing short of performance. It is clear that when the case was first presented to him, Kotlikoff, much like the fictional Dean Walker, was primarily concerned with protecting the reputations of the accused students. If he had addressed the situation with empathy for the victim, perhaps we wouldn’t be here two years later, demanding justice.
Following the assault, the victim has since withdrawn from Cornell. Since the investigation was reopened last month, the victim has reportedly received an overwhelming number of online threats. Within the last two years, five out of seven of the perpetrators were given the opportunity to complete their degrees and acquire their diplomas. The United States, despite being a country so obsessed with the phrase “let the punishment fit the crime”, it is clear that this principle has been applied selectively, if at all. The initial response to the “Cornell Seven” case was not to treat the seven criminals as men, but as boys. At seven years old, an essay might be punishment; at twenty-one, it is a complete and utter evasion of it.