Self-styled as “Ireland’s fastest growing political movement” in a recent opinion poll, Aontú’s climb to 9 per cent support marked a record high for the party and confirmed that Aontú’s political identity is on the rise. Exploiting a widespread sense of national decline and economic grievances, Independent Ireland similarly climbed the ranks to 7 per cent support. Now the two parties stand at a combined 16 per cent, on par with Fianna Fáil. This comes as 65 per cent of voters say they are unhappy with how the government is doing. While their rise does suggest populism is growing in Irish politics, could it amount to an ideological shift to the right?
In the post-war era, there have been four waves of political nationalism across Europe. The first two waves, spanning the 1950s to the 1970s, were largely unsuccessful in that their influence and effects were contained and curtailed. The third wave in the 1980s witnessed the rise of elected nationalist parties, such as the French National Front and the Italian Socialist Movement. However, these parties remained on the margins of political society due to a “political quarantine” imposed upon them by centrist and leftist parties. Whereas this movement was previously fragmented into various ideological camps, recent events and political victories have shown a more cohesive organisation of these groups. The fourth wave is what we are currently witnessing. As these parties become more mainstream and strategic, there now exists a monumental tidal wave towards the far right. This mainstreaming of far-right ideology is due in part to globalisation, in which far-right actors are able to “market” their ideology to a much larger and disenfranchised audience more susceptible to this messaging. Ireland has traditionally been a distinct outlier, absent from previous waves and surges of far-right movement, but with this rise in support for parties such as Aontú, is it being swept up alongside Europe in this fourth wave of far-right populism?
No one can deny the increased visibility of the far right in Ireland, particularly in online spaces. Though Ireland tries to hold firm to its traditional narrative that there is little organised extreme right-wing (ERW) presence in the country, in recent years this has proven to be false. Ireland has seen an increase in ERW and far-right activity, most prominently manifesting in online spaces through online activism. This has, in extreme cases, led to street protests and even riots. Social media firms enable otherwise small, minority networks to gain high visibility and traction, allowing them to garner a national reach.
Ireland is experiencing many of the conditions that have historically mainstreamed populist and far-right parties across Europe, with a high cost of living and rising inflation, along with one of the most severe housing crises in Europe. There is considerable scepticism of the government, with 66 per cent of Irish citizens believing there is corruption within the system, according to a 2026 European Commission report. Satisfaction with the government is at 29 per cent, a six-year low. Aontú’s populist rhetoric, with distinctly anti-government narratives and polarising opinions, has led to an undeniable rise in its popularity.
The 2025 presidential election shows this anti-establishment mood most clearly. 213,738 people spoiled their votes, almost 13 per cent of the total, not counting the further 7.2 per cent who voted for Jim Gavin. It was the single largest spoiled vote ever recorded in the State and one of the largest in modern European history in percentage terms, beating France’s 9 per cent, their highest since the creation of the Fifth Republic. This was almost 11 times the amount of spoiled votes from the 2018 presidential election, which stood at 1.2 per cent. Kevin Cunningham of Ireland Thinks argues that these voters are typically engaged with the democratic process, and the polling shows that interest in Maria Steen rose sharply, particularly on election day, suggesting that people were not so much interested in Aontú as they felt disenfranchised.
While Ireland is not unique in having an unpopular government, it is unique in that it is continuously reelected. 2024 saw the demise of incumbent governments across the world, with some notable exceptions, namely Ireland, which voted their incumbents back in. The unpopular government has returned time and time again because the opposition is also unpopular. Additionally, fragmentation within the smaller parties, with six parties below 10 per cent, makes government formation much more difficult. In the absence of a better opposition they can believe in, they will stick with the somewhat tolerable government, unless there is a significant change, potentially wrought by an economic shock. They also have nothing new to say: “we hate the government”, but who doesn’t? There are no broad and impactful ideas and statements to win over enough people to overturn the government.
While there is a minor shift towards support for parties such as Aontú, the shift is not occurring where it would be traditionally expected. Rural communities are not seeing the anticipated shift toward the conservative right, in part because of their lasting entrenchment within Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. Returning to the presidential elections, Dublin returned the highest spoiled votes, up to 20 per cent in some constituencies, with the shift happening in socioeconomically deprived areas such as Ballymun and Jobstown, suggesting Aontú’s success comes from economic grievance rather than a broader realignment of social values.
Sinn Féin remains Ireland’s largest and most popular party and sits on the left. Inclusivity is a key part of its ideology, publicly speaking in support of the rights of immigrants, Travellers, the LGBTQ+ community, and other minority groups. Its policy “Many Voices, One Country” opposes racism and discrimination. Sinn Féin’s dominance shows how large the anti-establishment vote is, though it no longer holds this space alone. Aontú’s gains arriving while Sinn Féin remains popular suggests the populist space is expanding, but apart from a fringe minority, the growth in right-wing ideology remains sporadic and peripheral.
The objection from public opinion is similar. The Hope and Courage Collective’s “Ireland in Focus 2025” report found that 66 per cent of citizens believe immigrants contribute to the Irish community (up two per cent from 2024) and that most reject far-right narratives. “Grievance-driven narratives” are currently being deployed to sustain momentum in the absence of broad support. Symbolic actions, such as the use of the tricolour, portray the movement as being greater than its actual size. 79 per cent believe working-class people are struggling due to systemic inequality, also up 2 per cent from 2024. Those who believe wealthy people are successful because they were given more opportunities than others have risen from 63 per cent in 2024 to 69 per cent in 2025. The number of people who support the freedom of transgender people to live their lives is up 5 per cent from 70 per cent in 2024. This does not mark a shift towards right-wing ideology.
Although the conditions appear to be perfect for the right to thrive, there are significant statistics to suggest that people do not necessarily believe the narrative. Aontú’s conservative social agenda is out of step with most voters, and its success depends on an anti-government mood that Sinn Féin also taps into. Ireland is experiencing a populist moment without a mass far-right movement. We can take learnings from the recent Brexit experience, as it clarifies that a positive political response to right-wing movements such as Reform can be very damaging for the overall and long-term economic, political, and reputational health of a country. However, similarly to the Brexit debacle, if the positive side of a multicultural society is not highlighted sufficiently and visibly, it does provide growing space for the negative narrative to fester.