Comment & Analysis
Oct 23, 2026

Has Ryan Murphy Gone Too Far?

The TV titan’s latest endeavour, a series dramatising the life of Lizzie Borden, is sub-par even by his own standards

Archie MarksContributing Writer
blank
Borden in 1890 Via Creative Commons

Shortly after the identity of Luigi Mangione — the killer of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson —- was revealed in December 2024, a tweet from @spilling_the_t (well!) read: “Can’t wait to see Dave Franco play Luigi Mangione in whatever TV series Ryan Murphy is currently creating.” Indeed, Murphy’s name has become shorthand for topical, controversial projects, like “Scream Queens” — a crime-comedy series that, in its first episode, features Ariana Grande as a sorority member who attempts to delay her own murder by sending a tweet. Highbrow, indeed.

Perhaps Murphy’s most critiqued endeavour to date has been his ongoing “Monster” TV series. Co-created with Ian Brennan for Netflix, the series purports to expose the “unconscionable” crimes committed by some of America’s most notorious killers, with a particular focus on “the underserved victims and their communities impacted by the systemic racism and institutional failures of the police.” (Per a press release for the first series.) Each instalment focuses on a different “monster”, from Jeffrey Dahmer and the Menendez brothers to Ed Gein and, now, Lizzie Borden.

Borden’s series, released in full on Netflix mid-September, spans a brief period of her lifetime: the buildup to and occurrence of her father and stepmother’s murder, and her subsequent trial and acquittal. The series,, like previous “Monster” instalments, has been a hit with viewers; it became the third series of the show to debut at the top spot of Netflix’s global weekly chart, a convoluted way of saying that it has been very, very popular.

ADVERTISEMENT

It is also, according to critics, very, very bad. Sitting at a tepid 38 per cent on review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, the series has been panned. Vulture called it “hollow”; IndieWire “lazy”; The Guardian “utterly bonkers [and] borderline-fetishistic.” Aside from shallow plotting and tonal mismatch, a main point of contention — as with each other instalment of “Monster” — is the historical liberties taken; how Murphy and his collaborators skate over the facts and make up others, often opting for the most shocking or puerile take on matters.

For instance, Borden’s menstruation is a pointed focus, particularly in the first episode; a painful cramp dissuades a potential suitor, and later, Borden enrages her stepmother Abby by bleeding on her ornate silk sofa. (Foreshadowing, anyone?) This might have been a useful motif if the writers of the series weren’t All Cisgender Men, or had anything beyond a cursory interest in the themes of female oppression and sexuality. But even the little that the series has to say about those themes is trite and recycled, and you can practically feel Brennan and Murphy winking through the camera: Female oppression spanning across generations, am I right?

But — and call me the Woker — I hardly think a tale of parricide is fertile ground for a girlboss moment at all. The historical liberties taken in “Monster” are amusingly crude at best, downright irresponsible at worst: a focal point is the notorious twentieth-century killer Aileen Wuornos (who murdered seven people between 1989 and 1990, over a century after Borden’s murders) visiting the Borden home. Again, this might have been forgiven if the creatives had anything of interest to say about (for instance) popular culture’s treatment of troubled women. But in playing fast and loose with the most disturbing chapters of modern history, Murphy and co. risk trivialising it.

This, of course, is of little concern to Murphy, who has long been criticised for style-over-substance approach. Murphy’s popularity lies not in his ability to excavate potent character arcs — he’s about as incisive as a butter knife in that regard — but in his ability to use our dopamine receptors as a Whac-a-Mole game, appealing to our basest, most primal hungers of blood and scandal.

Murphy’s inclination to shock and seduce in “Monster” speaks to the fatal flaw of true crime as a genre: in reducing real, harrowing stories down to crude and shocking pleasures,one risks exploiting — and thus negating — those caught in the crosshairs. The first instalment of “Monster”, focusing on Jeffrey Dahmer, was met with fierce backlash for scenes that allegedly sexualised and sympathised with the serial killer by focusing disproportionately on Dahmer’s inner life and not on that of any of his seventeen victims — many of whom were gay, Black, or both. That’s without mentioning the lack of contact made with (or consent obtained from) Dahmer’s victims’ families.

Worse still is the following season, which focused on brothers Erik and Lyle Menendez (who, like Borden, committed parricide). The brothers, who were each sexually and physically abused by their parents, are implied to have an incestuous relationship with one another; a not-insignificant part of the series plays out like a Sean Cody advert, the brothers clad in Speedos and moving like they’re auditioning for a TikTok edit. Of all the descriptors one could deploy — obscenely tasteless, grossly insensitive — none would suffice, if only because none would stop more getting made.

Because, as much as we mock and shame Murphy and other purveyors of true crime, the draw of it  — the thrill of fear and danger from a safe distance, the desire to understand human darkness — remains. No matter that a compulsive, prolonged engagement with the worst of humanity might well cause a distorted worldview (ever wondered if your neighbour was hiding bodies in the attic?), or that sensationalisation of crime in general can have armchair detectives interfering with real police work — as it did in 2023, when the disappearance of English woman Nicola Bulley attracted so much trespassing and conspiracy theories that police had to issue dispersal orders.

The distillation of crime to a genre to be enjoyed and theorised, and not a serious issue affecting real people, means that when it happens — in the media or in real life — we may not treat it with the gravity it deserves. I think, for instance, of the way Luigi Mangione was heralded as a sex symbol when his identity was uncovered. This isn’t to excuse the predatory insurance companies Mangione has such vitriol towards, but rather to ask: would we be as defensive of Mangione if he wasn’t conventionally attractive, if his backstory was less easy to transform into a hero’s journey? Would he be facing such severe condemnation from the ruling class if he wasn’t essentially a pop culture icon?

These crime series are altering the way we view real-life cases, to the extent that the mass fascination of criminals risks redeeming them. This isn’t to say these affairs are completely devoid of value; the production design is always expensive-looking, and the casts of “Monster” each turn in fine performances. But how many more rides on the carousel must we slump through before we draw the line? My guess — and I’m not immune from the base, alluring appeal of a cobbled-together crime series, either — is that we won’t. If and when Murphy does make that Luigi Mangione series, I anticipate a repeat of the old charade: wagging one finger in disappointment, with the other hand on the remote, clicking “Skip Intro”.

Sign Up to Our Weekly Newsletters

Get The University Times into your inbox twice a week.