On the otherwise beautiful morning of September 22nd, I was approached by a member of Trinity’s security staff and forced to break up a group of family and friends I was leading on what was, apparently, an unauthorised campus tour.
About a month before fall classes resumed, my great aunt, Geraldine, texted me to ask if I could lead a tour of Trinity for her, her sister Ursula, and a group of their friends coming to Dublin in late September. I was elated! I would get to see two of my grandmother’s sisters, as well as a group of dear family friends. I was not getting paid to show them around. I would be showing Ger and Urs around anyway, they just happened to be with a larger group. Around twelve people total, all of whom I knew. We were going to get lunch after, before my afternoon classes.
I’ve always counted myself lucky to attend college on such a beautiful, historic campus. I’ve told my family all about it over the years, and now I was going to get to show them the real thing.
As a Trinity student, I am very aware of the high-traffic areas of campus, and when I was planning our route, I tried to find the best places for us to stop while also staying out of everyone’s way. I did not plan to bring anyone into any buildings. But, we didn’t make it past front square before a security guard came up to us and told me I was leading an unauthorised tour and we needed to immediately disperse. I thought, at first, it must be a misunderstanding. I was not aware of Trinity’s campus tour policy at the time. I had done a cursory Google search the night before and did not find any policy preventing me from leading an unpaid, informal tour for people I knew. I explained to the security guard that I was a Trinity student, and the group was family and friends. She made it clear it was still an unauthorised tour, and followed us until the group broke up. I was confused and, frankly, embarrassed. I had promised Ger a tour of my campus, and I was genuinely excited to give it! My group was very sympathetic because they did not want me to get in any trouble, but I was still convinced this must be a misunderstanding.
I found out later, from Ger, that the same security guard had approached members of my group afterwards and asked if I had “solicited” them for a tour. I’m glad I was not aware of that at the time. I would just have been more embarrassed and angry. Because the most embarrassing part of the whole ordeal was that my family was seeing my college treat me this way.
I put a message about this in DU History’s committee group chat, asking if anyone had heard of this policy. Our secretary, Emma, mentioned something similar had nearly happened the week previous , just before our freshers week walking tour of Dublin . The tour’s meeting point was in front of the campanile, and a member of Trinity’s security staff nearly forced them to disperse because of Trinity’s policy against “unauthorized campus tours”. The difference was that tour was not actually taking place on campus, and so it was allowed to continue after the participants showed their T-Cards.
I wanted to get to the bottom of this so I emailed Trinity enquiries, who eventually directed me to the head of Visitor Experience and Operations, Gemma Sexton. I thought maybe the size of my group was the reason the tour was “unauthorised”, and that I would need approval for safety reasons (though, we were only walking around outside an otherwise open campus). Over a protracted email exchange I learned that, yes, there was a policy that prohibited nearly all campus tours not authorized by Trinity trails. No, the size of the group did not matter. I explicitly asked about an instance where I had shown my father and sister around a couple years previously. Apparently, that would qualify as an unauthorized tour as well. I was just fortunate not to be noticed by security that time. Trinity’s security staff has the discretion to enforce this policy against any and all “tours” of any size. Members of Trinity staff who wanted to lead campus tours must seek approval from Trinity Trails. We still don’t know if DU History, as a student society, would be allowed to lead our own walking tour of Trinity.
How can unpaid, student led tours meaningfully interfere with Trinity Trails? The third aim of Trinity’s campus tour policy is, “To increase revenue for the University.” As a student paying international tuition, the university already makes a considerable amount of revenue from me. I would hope that would grant me the basic right to show people I know around my campus, a campus that is open to the general public already.
Nearly everyone I talked to about this policy either did not know it existed, or assumed there would be an exemption for students. There is not. As long as it exists in its current state, Trinity’s security staff can and do enforce it against students. It is also not an easy policy to locate, which is why DU History now has it linked in our Instagram bio. I only have access to it because it was sent to me by Ms Sexton. When I asked her for clarification on where I could find it myself, all she could tell me was that it was on the TCD website. Which is not at all an easy site to navigate. I still have not managed to find it linked there.
The committee of DU History agreed this policy was unfair to students. We decided to put out a statement explaining it to the wider student body, and soliciting feedback from our membership. Trinity puts its history behind a hefty paywall for outsiders. Why must it do the same for its students, and their loved ones? I would be showing family and friends around my campus even if it wasn’t one of Ireland’s most lucrative tourist attractions. But because it is, I don’t have any right to.
Trinity students deserve to be able to show their loved ones our campus. Trinity must amend its campus tour policy to make this unambiguously clear.