Picture this: you’ve been dating your lovely, curly-haired boyfriend for a couple months now, when suddenly he shows up to a dinner date with a fresh buzz cut. You immediately get a massive ick, and he stares at you in confusion while you explain that he’s more like a brother to you. Oh well. Time to reactivate your Hinge profile.
Most people would probably not actually break up over an unexpected haircut, but this mentality is becoming increasingly recognisable in the way young people think and talk about dating. Romantic partners are easily disposed of if they fail to live up to certain standards: one should “never settle”. While this is reasonable in many cases, it can also lead to a never-ending chase of a “perfect” relationship.
The blame is often put on social media for having created unrealistic expectations for romantic relationships. After all, it’s not easy to compete with the conventionally attractive couples on social media who seem to have infinite free time for weekend getaways and daily dinner dates. However, the consumption of idealised romance is hardly a new phenomenon: there have always been films, poetry and love songs. Austen’s “Pride and Prejudice” has been around for 213 years, and yet it has not caused generations of readers to discard their boyfriends for failing to resemble Mr Darcy. So why does dating in the digital age feel so loveless?
The answer might be that modern dating has little to do with love and much more to do with consumption culture. Dating apps and social media haven’t just set the standards high; they’ve conditioned young people to prioritise surface-level ‘features’ over organic connection. A potential partner’s carefully curated Instagram profile becomes their personal brand label: their hobbies, interests and favourite artists will be evaluated before committing to the purchase. It’s almost like shopping for a new phone, except you’ll probably hold onto your phone for longer.
Like shopping for a phone, picking a partner also becomes overwhelming when faced with a myriad of different options on dating apps. The illusion of infinite supply leads to a lower tolerance for any flaws: people start optimising for maximum reward — the prettiest, the richest, the most athletic — rather than looking for deep intimacy and vulnerability. If your partner isn’t perfect, they can always be traded for someone better.
At the root of this consumerist logic is the hope for self-benefit. Once you have secured yourself the perfect product, you must make good use of it. In the past few years, social media has popularised the concept of the “bare minimum”. More traditionally, it means the basic requirements for a relationship to function — honesty, respect, communication — but on social media, the concept has been twisted into something more elaborate. Buying flowers is the bare minimum. Paying for every dinner date is the bare minimum. Even expensive surprise trips are, by some chronically online American influencers, considered the bare minimum. In other words, the bare minimum has become the minimum benefit that one should gain from a relationship.
The issue with the “bare minimum” mentality isn’t having expectations. Naturally, it’s important to have standards when choosing someone to potentially spend the rest of your life with. However, when specific expectations become the epicentre of one’s dating life, it leaves less space for genuine displays of affection: this is where relationships risk becoming transactional. If both partners are constantly keeping score of the cost-benefit ratio, they will feel less inclined to go out of their way for one another because they’re not receiving anything in return. Gifts and gestures of affection are seen as something that is owed rather than something to be appreciated, leaving both parties underwhelmed.
While dating culture is becoming increasingly transactional, that doesn’t mean that true romance must only exist on screen. In fact, it may be just the opposite: intimacy can only truly exist far from social media. A Boston University study suggests that couples with less screen time tend to report higher relationship satisfaction. Indeed, logging off can alleviate the pressure of constantly having to perform better than the endless competition on social media. It paves the way for authenticity and leaves space for couples to embrace imperfection and unconditional love. So if your boyfriend turns up to your next date night looking suspiciously like a trimmed hedgehog, think twice about what the real issue is: his haircut, or the damn phone?