Comment & Analysis
Oct 25, 2026

The UN General Assembly: Progress or Pantomime?

While controversy marked the opening of debate at the UNGA, action on AI and the race for a new Secretary-General provides some hope for the United Nations

Patrick Fanning Contributing Writer
blank
Image via Creative Commons

World leaders and diplomats of the 193 member states of the United Nations descended on New York last month for the opening of the 81st session of the United Nations General Assembly. It will sit for most of the year, but it’s unlikely that its work will draw as much attention as it did during the high-level General Debate. That took place during the week of September 21st, and saw world leaders address the General Assembly (GA) and their fellow leaders. Constructive speeches were overshadowed by countries who have trampled all over the UN’s values of peace, multilateralism, equality, & human dignity getting up on the podium and preaching about the importance of their warmongering policies. Donald Trump justified his actions in Iran and Venezuela, and Binyamin Netanyahu defended Israel’s assault on Gaza (in front of a half-empty chamber, after many delegates walked out before his speech). The UAE emphasised the need for peace in Sudan, despite their military backing of the Rapid Support Forces, one side in that country’s devastating civil war. Overall, the week felt like a bit of a spit in the face for idealists. 

For those tempted to dismiss the whole thing as a farce, the theme for the 81st session doesn’t help: “Restoring trust, managing transformation: A United Nations that delivers for all”. After a week where the debate seemed more divided than ever, trust is not at a high point in international politics. Could “managing transformation” be a bit more promising? Artificial intelligence (AI) and its potential to transform the world economy comes to mind. Many fine words were said on the topic during the debate; China committed to develop AI for good and to narrow the digital divide, while the UK emphasised its hope to create global principles for the safe development of AI. Notably, though, when the time came to sign an agreement on the topic, China and the UK were absent.  

The Call for Control of Frontier AI Models, led by Norway and Finland, aims to maintain human oversight and regulation of AI, among other things. It received only 22 signatures, representing just over 10 per cent of the member nations of the UN. This is despite an urgent call for governments to sign an agreement on international red lines for AI, made during the GA’s last session. Trump must bear part of the blame for the lack of movement towards global oversight of AI. In his speech he firmly rejected any global attempts to regulate AI, using the celebratory term ‘Super Intelligence’ rather than artificial intelligence. That gives other countries less room to cooperate on AI governance even if they wanted to do so. Both the US and China fear they will fall behind in the race for development of AI if too much regulation is imposed, and the UK may prefer to strike a compromise with the US. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite the lack of agreement around rules for AI, the UN is doing what it can in smaller ways. At the last session of the GA, an International Independent Scientific Panel on AI and a Global Dialogue on AI Governance were established. The Panel published its first brief in advance of the high-level week, reporting on an incident during the summer where OpenAI agents went rogue and hacked another platform, Hugging Face. While it could have made more of an impact at the General Debate, its risk management recommendations to imitate nuclear safety and its many protective layers will be useful guidelines if the debate on this topic advances. Furthermore, its reports do not have to be approved by the UN, meaning its findings are apolitical. With the exponential development of AI, we need trusted, independent sources of information such as this. 

The UN also provides a forum for young people to weigh in on AI. On August 12th, International Youth Day 2026, youth delegates presented a declaration on AI policy and governance, calling for more youth involvement in AI governance. A similar document, the AI Charter, was presented by the Global Youth AI Advisory Body to the 81st session of the GA. These are not official UN policy instruments, and were not signed by member nations, meaning they won’t have an immediate impact on policy. But recording the perspectives of young people on AI in this way is hopefully an incentive for countries to take them into account, and the UN has pledged to consider these in its development of AI policy. These measures don’t do what we need in regulating AI, but that’s a very difficult task when the US, home of a very significant proportion of AI companies, is actively opposed to any efforts to do so. Rather, they will hopefully encourage and shape efforts to regulate AI outside of the UN for the better.  

This idea of the UN as a smaller body, focusing on acting in areas where it can be effective, is present in the vision statements of several candidates to be the next Secretary-General of the UN. António Guterres, the ninth UN Secretary-General, will finish his term at the end of this year. Seven candidates are looking to replace him; the successful one will be appointed by the General Assembly on the recommendation of the Security Council. Important factors in the selection process will be that there has been no female Secretary-General yet, and that norms around regional rotation favour Latin America and the Caribbean, who have not had a Secretary-General since 1991. This is reflected in the most recent anonymous poll of the Security Council. The frontrunners are Rebeca Grynspan, Secretary-General of UN Trade and Development (UNCTAD) and former Vice President of Costa Rica, and Rafael Grossi, Director of the International Atomic Energy Agency and former Argentinian diplomat. 

How closely should we be watching this race — could it be transformative for the UN? The candidates’ vision statements don’t necessarily suggest so. Grynspan and Grossi both speak about a greater role for the Secretary General in mediating conflicts and maintaining dialogue with member nations, as well as institutional reform, streamlining the processes of the UN. Grynspan references better accountability for the UN, and early-warning systems for conflict, while Grossi focuses on development, and partnership with the private sector, financial institutions and civil society to meet goals in that area.  

While they both may improve the United Nations in their own way, how far will they advance it towards a body that is capable of maintaining peace and achieving global governance? There is no reference to Security Council reform in their manifestos, nor to increasing the powers of the General Assembly. That may be a process fault though rather than an individual lack of imagination. The permanent five members of the Security Council –- the US, Russia, France, China and the UK — can veto any candidate, as they can for any decision of the SC. When the process is reliant on the consent of countries for whom the status quo is so favourable, it seems hard to imagine a candidate who will transform that status quo being elected.  

We shouldn’t pin our hopes for world peace on this race then, but maybe we can hope for a UN that will be more efficient and effective, and one that focuses on the areas where it can make a positive impact, transformative or not, as it has been doing for AI. We might have to reduce our ambitions for the UN, but we shouldn’t write it off yet. 

Sign Up to Our Weekly Newsletters

Get The University Times into your inbox twice a week.